Aller au contenu
Réserver une démo Essai gratuit

ComparerBibliothèque

Koha vs ProHQ

Koha is a free, open source integrated library system with cataloguing, circulation, acquisitions and serials, installed on your own server or hosted by a support company.

Essai gratuit Informations vérifiées le 12 novembre 2026
Koha
ProHQ
Le prix commence à
Sur devis
$10 par personne et par mois
Gratuit à l'essai
The software itself is free under the GPL version 3 or later.
15 jours de tout, gratuits
Agents IA
Non
Oui
Assistant IA
Oui
Oui
Langues
Oui
Oui
Fonctionne hors ligne
En partie
Oui
Vos propres applications
Oui
Oui
Fait pour
Open source library management system
Toute entreprise : des applications prêtes pour bibliothèque, et n'importe quelle application à vous en quelques minutes

Ce qu'est Koha

Koha calls itself the first free software library automation package. Work on it began on 6 September 1999 in New Zealand, when Katipo Communications wrote it for the Horowhenua Library Trust, whose old system had a year 2000 problem. It went live on 3 January 2000 and is licensed under the GNU General Public License. No single company owns it: a community steers it and ships two feature releases a year, the latest being 26.05 on 26 May 2026. Koha covers what a professional library expects: acquisitions, circulation, cataloguing in MARC 21 and UNIMARC, serials, authorities, reports, label printing, notices, a public catalogue and self-checkout, and newer versions add recalls, bookings, curbside pickup and electronic resource management. Wikipedia cites a 2017 description of it as the most widely implemented open source library system in the world, and names Turkey's Ministry of Culture running it across 1,136 public libraries. The software costs nothing. A library installs it on a Linux server, or pays one of the independent companies that host and support it. Public, school, special and some large academic libraries use it.

koha-community.org

Les points forts de Koha

  • No licence fee, and the code is yours

    Koha is free under the GPL version 3 or later, and the project states there is no vendor lock-in and that a library can export its data at any time.

  • Cataloguing to professional standards

    MARC 21, UNIMARC, authorities and copy cataloguing from other libraries over Z39.50 and SRU are core, which matters to any library that shares records.

  • A deep circulation desk

    Holds, recalls, bookings, curbside pickup, transfers between branches, web self-checkout and self check-in are all in its manual, with SIP2 and NCIP for kiosks.

  • Acquisitions, serials and e-resources together

    Ordering from vendors with EDIFACT, journals as serials, and an electronic resources dashboard with usage figures sit in the same system.

  • An active community in many languages

    Two feature releases a year, frequent maintenance releases, a public manual, and 30 languages listed in the 26.05 release notes.

Comment ProHQ s'y prend

Koha is one kind of software, and a very complete one: a library system that begins at the catalogue record and rewards a trained librarian with depth. ProHQ is a different kind of thing, the platform a whole organisation runs on, and its Library app is one part of it. That app is ready the day it is installed: titles and copies with spine codes, members who become Active only when their payment is verified, fourteen-day loans, late fees billed by themselves, points, referrals, coupons and events. Readers hold light seats and join, borrow, return and pay from their own phones. Around the app sits everything else a library, a school or a trust needs: buying, the books, staff attendance, leave and payroll, tasks, documents and chat, all under one sign-in. An AI assistant answers from the records and acts on them in each person's language, agents do routine chasing by themselves, reminders leave from the library's own WhatsApp number, and each role is taught by a lesson played inside the app. Whatever is particular to your library is asked for in plain words and made, with no server to keep and no code to write.

Les applications ProHQ pour cela Bibliothèque

Un à un

Koha et ProHQ, fonction par fonction.

49 fonctions comparées

The catalogue and buying books

Koha's catalogue is its heart, with MARC records and authority control that a trained cataloguer expects, and ordering and journals built around it. ProHQ's Library app keeps a simpler shelf: a title, its copies, a spine code on each. Buying and anything rarer come from the platform around the app.

The catalogue and buying books: Koha vs ProHQ
FonctionKohaProHQ
Titles and copies Oui

Bibliographic records with items under each, in MARC 21 or UNIMARC, with authorities as a core module.

Oui

A title is the work and each physical copy is its own record under it, with its shelf, condition and whether it was bought or donated.

Bibliothèque
Adding a new book quickly Oui

Fast Add frameworks, several since 26.05, and copy cataloguing from other libraries by Z39.50 or SRU.

En partie

A title is typed with its author, ISBN, language and category, or the assistant reads a list or a photo and adds the rows.

Bibliothèque
Spine codes and labels Oui

Item barcodes, with label printing as a core module.

Oui

Every copy carries a spine code on its sticker, and a copy with no code is flagged for the cataloguer.

Bibliothèque
Reader reviews and ratings Oui

Patrons leave comments and star ratings in the public catalogue.

Oui

A reader's review is moderated, then published; its stars join the title's average and earn the reader points.

Bibliothèque
Finding a book from a phone Oui

The public catalogue has a mobile view in the phone's browser, with holds, renewals and lists.

Oui

A reader searches the catalogue in their own app, or scans a spine, and sees which copies are in.

Bibliothèque
Readers asking for a title Oui

Purchase suggestions are made from the public catalogue.

Oui

A wanted book sits in the catalogue as Requested, with a note of who asked, until it is bought.

Bibliothèque
Ordering from booksellers Oui

Acquisitions with vendors is core, with EDIFACT ordering and a redesigned message viewer in 26.05.

Oui

A request for books goes to suppliers for quotes, becomes an order, is received, and the invoice is matched against both.

procurement
Journals and magazines Oui

Serials is a core module.

Oui

Say 'a register of subscriptions with each expected issue, the day it arrived and a reminder when one is late' and it is ready.

builder

Members

Koha sorts patrons into categories, each with its own fees and rules. ProHQ follows a member along a path a club recognises: applied, payment pending, payment being verified, Active. Signing up is not membership, and nor is paying, until the desk has seen the money.

Members: Koha vs ProHQ
FonctionKohaProHQ
Member records Oui

Patron records in categories that are set up before patrons are added.

Oui

Each member has a card number, plan, fee and validity; their name and phone live in the shared contact book.

Bibliothèque
Joining from home Oui

Patrons can register for their own accounts through the public catalogue, if the library allows it.

Oui

A reader joins from their phone and uploads a payment screenshot; the desk verifies it and makes them Active.

Bibliothèque
Membership fee and plans Oui

An enrolment fee is charged to the patron's account when it is created.

Oui

Quarterly, half-yearly and annual plans each carry a fee, and the card is good for the plan's months.

Bibliothèque
Expiry and renewal Oui

A patron can renew their membership from the Summary tab of the public catalogue, and a renewal fee is charged to the account.

Oui

A week before a card runs out the member is told what renewing costs; the morning after its last day, the card is Expired.

Bibliothèque
Members owing money held back Oui

Checkout is blocked above a fine limit, which staff may override on renewal since 26.05.

Oui

A reader borrows only when Active, with fewer than three books out and nothing owed.

Bibliothèque
Consent and reading privacy Oui

A Privacy tab for how long reading history is kept, a Consents tab, and anonymising of circulation history.

Oui

Consent is kept on record, and a person can take a copy of their data or have it deleted on request.

safety

Lending and returns

Koha's desk goes further than most libraries will ever need: holds, recalls, bookings, pickup at the kerb. ProHQ's rule is one a small library can say aloud: fourteen days, three books, nothing owed. Where it goes further is the reader's own phone, which does the borrowing.

Lending and returns: Koha vs ProHQ
FonctionKohaProHQ
Issuing a book Oui

Check out at the desk is core circulation.

Oui

One copy lent to one member for fourteen days; the copy leaves the shelf the same moment.

Bibliothèque
Self checkout by the reader Oui

A web self-checkout screen, switched on by a preference and run under a dedicated staff account.

Oui

A reader scans the spine with their own phone and photographs the covers, and the loan begins.

Bibliothèque
Returning a book Oui

Check in at the desk, or a self check-in module that works with a barcode scanner.

Oui

The reader asks to return from their phone; the desk inspects the copy and it goes back on the shelf, or to Damaged.

Bibliothèque
Holds on a book that is out Oui

Holds are placed by staff or in the public catalogue, with a holds queue and, since 26.05, hold fees by category, item type and library.

Oui

Ask for a waiting list on a title - who is waiting, in what order, told when a copy comes back - and it is added to the app as a draft to publish.

builder
Recalls, bookings and curbside pickup Oui

Recalls with reports, items made bookable for a date, and scheduled curbside pickup are in the circulation manual.

Oui

Describe a booking of a copy for a day, or a pickup slot with its time and who collects, and it is made with its reminders.

builder
Reminders and notices Oui

Notices are a core module, sent by email, print or SMS.

Oui

The evening before a book is due the member is reminded, and a loan that turns Overdue is told at once with the fee that follows.

Bibliothèque
Lost copies Non indiqué

The manual pages read did not cover how a lost item is charged.

Oui

A lost copy is retired and the member is charged its book value.

Bibliothèque

Fines, points and coupons

Koha has real accounting for a library: invoices, payments, write-offs, credits and refunds on each patron. ProHQ bills late, damage and lost-copy fines each as its own record, then adds what a readers' club uses to bring people back: points, referrals and coupon codes that take money off.

Fines, points and coupons: Koha vs ProHQ
FonctionKohaProHQ
Late fees Oui

Overdue fines are worked out from the circulation rules.

Oui

A book back late is billed its fee for each day after two days' grace, as a fine of its own.

Bibliothèque
Damage fees Oui

Staff raise a manual invoice on the patron's account.

Oui

A damage fee set at inspection raises its own fine, apart from any late fee.

Bibliothèque
Waiving a fine Oui

Write-offs, cancellations, voided payments, credits and refunds are in the accounting section, each under a permission.

Oui

A fine can be waived only with its reason written down, and the reason stays in its history.

Bibliothèque
Paying a fine from a phone Non indiqué

The public catalogue pages read do not say whether a patron can pay online.

Oui

A reader pays a fine from their app with a payment screenshot, and the desk verifies it before the fine is settled.

Bibliothèque
Coupon codes Non

Manual credits exist; no coupon codes are described.

Oui

A code takes money off a membership fee, a fine or an event's entry, and each use is counted.

Bibliothèque
Loyalty points Non

A points scheme is not among Koha's modules.

Oui

Returns, published reviews, events, donated books and approved claims earn points, on a rate card you can edit.

Bibliothèque
Referrals Non

A referral scheme is not among Koha's modules.

Oui

When a referred member becomes Active, both they and the member who brought them are credited.

Bibliothèque
Events with sign-up Non

Event booking is not a module; patron clubs are the nearest thing.

Oui

Reading circles, author talks and workshops open for registration, remind people the day before and give points for attending.

Bibliothèque

Running the library

Koha gives a librarian reports written as queries and permissions for single actions. ProHQ gives a head librarian a dashboard that is already drawn and staff roles that are already set. One asks for skill and repays it; the other asks for nothing on the first morning.

Running the library: Koha vs ProHQ
FonctionKohaProHQ
Reports and dashboard Oui

Guided reports, SQL reports and statistics wizards, exported as CSV, tab-separated text or ODS and run on a schedule.

Oui

Active members, books out, overdue, fines owed, most borrowed, shelf status and more, thirteen reports on one dashboard.

Bibliothèque
Staff roles Oui

Permissions for single actions; restoring a deleted record, new in 26.05, has its own.

Oui

Head librarian, front desk and cataloguer each see their own work; a reader sees only their own records.

Bibliothèque
Approvals En partie

Purchase suggestions, discharges and changes a patron asks for wait for staff; there is no general workflow builder.

Oui

Any record can wait for the right person's yes, in steps you set, answered on a phone.

approvals
No server to look after En partie

Only when a support company hosts it for a fee; otherwise the library runs its own Linux server.

Oui

Nothing to install or upgrade, and everything is backed up every day.

safety
Help when stuck Oui

Free help on community mailing lists and chat; paid support by contract with a vendor, whose hours are its own.

Oui

Ask the assistant how to do something and it answers, or plays the lesson for that step on your own screen.

assistant

Beyond the library system

Koha is a library system and stops, properly, at the library's edge. ProHQ is the platform around the Library app: an assistant and agents that do work, readers and staff in their own language, WhatsApp, lessons, and the organisation's buying, staff, pay and books under the same sign-in.

Beyond the library system: Koha vs ProHQ
FonctionKohaProHQ
AI assistant Non

None in the project; one vendor lists AI-enabled searching extensions as a paid extra.

Oui

Ask in your own language who has a book or what is overdue, or tell it to add a member, and it does it within what you may do.

assistant
AI agents that work by themselves Non

Agents are not among Koha's modules.

Oui

Give an agent a job on a timetable, such as chasing unpaid fines; it waits for approval before it sends, and shows what it did.

agents
Interface languages Oui

30 languages in the 26.05 release notes, each with a percentage done: Hindi 90%, Arabic 87%, Telugu 62%.

Oui

Fifteen built in, Hindi, Tamil, Telugu, Kannada, Bengali and Urdu among them, and any other added the first time someone picks it.

languages
Working with no network En partie

A Firefox add-on and a Windows tool record check-outs and check-ins to upload once the system is back; nothing for a phone.

Oui

The app keeps working on a weak signal, on the desk's computer or a reader's phone, and sends what was done when the network returns.

offline
Phone apps Non

The project has no official phone app; staff and readers use the website in a browser.

Oui

The same app on Android, iOS and a computer, installed in a tap.

phone
Readers and helpers on low-cost seats Oui

Koha has no per-user price at all, so patrons and staff are never charged by the seat.

Oui

Readers hold light seats: their card, finding and borrowing a book, their shelf and what is on, paid for only in months they are active.

light seats
Training for new staff En partie

A detailed public manual; hands-on training is sold by vendors.

Oui

A short lesson for each role plays inside the real app, with a safe copy of the library to practise in.

lessons
WhatsApp to members Non

Notices go by email, print and SMS; WhatsApp is not one of its channels.

Oui

Due dates, fines, renewals and the welcome with a card number go from the library's own WhatsApp number.

whatsapp
Connections to other systems Oui

Z39.50, SRU, SIP2, NCIP, EDIFACT, SUSHI, plugins and a REST API: the standards libraries share.

Oui

More than 80 everyday apps connect, from mail and calendar to sheets and payments, each by signing in to your own account.

integrations
Changing how the library works En partie

System preferences and plugins; beyond those, a developer changes the code.

Oui

Ask for a new field, step or report, or a whole new app; it is prepared as a draft and goes live when you say so.

builder
Where data is kept Oui

On the library's own server by default, or wherever its vendor hosts; the project holds no certification of its own.

Oui

Stored encrypted in India, the United States or Europe, with a history of every change; an enterprise can run it in its own cloud.

safety
Staff attendance and leave Non

Not among Koha's modules.

Oui

Staff check in by location, shifts sit on a roster, and leave is asked for and approved on the phone.

Présence
Payroll Non

Not among Koha's modules.

Oui

Salaries are computed with their deductions explained on a payslip, then paid and booked.

payroll
The organisation's books Non

It keeps patron accounts and acquisitions; general accounting is not among its modules.

Oui

Invoices, bills, receipts and the bank are kept as the trust's or school's books in the same account.

finance
Tasks and staff chat Non

Not among Koha's modules.

Oui

A task has an owner and a due day, and staff and volunteers message one to one or in groups, beside the library's work.

tasks

ProHQ en entier

Koha fait un seul travail. ProHQ fait tourner toute l'entreprise.

Tout ce qui précède compare un type de logiciel. Avec ProHQ, c'est une partie d'une plateforme sur laquelle toute votre entreprise travaille.

Tarifs

Ce que coûte Koha, et ce que coûte ProHQ.

Tarifs de Koha

Free open source software with no per-user price. A library pays for its own server and staff time, or a support company's fee for hosting, migration and help, which most companies quote.

  • Koha, self-installedFree

    Every module, under the GPL version 3 or later, on the library's own Linux server.

  • Hosted by a support companyQuoted by each vendor

    Independent companies in the community's directory sell hosting, migration, training and support; the community gives none of them official status.

  • One vendor's printed prices (Prosentient Systems)About 2,320 a year for each library or branch, currency not stated on the page

    Hosting on a shared cloud in Australia or Europe, with 600 once for website setup and 1,200 once for configuration, all printed as GST inclusive.

Formule gratuite ou essaiThe software itself is free under the GPL version 3 or later.

En plus du prix affichéProsentient's page also prints data conversion at 600 for a MARC catalogue, training at 1,100 for a half-day module, customisation at 220 an hour and single sign-on setup at 990, in the same unnamed currency. Another company, KohaSupport, sells a Standard plan through a cloud marketplace and an Enterprise plan by quote, with a 30-day trial. A self-hosting library carries its own server, backups and two upgrades a year.

D'après la page de tarifs de Koha

Tarifs de ProHQ

  • Starter$10 par personne et par mois

    The shared records, documents, sheets, forms, reports and the assistant, for a small team: three apps.

  • Basic$20 par personne et par mois

    Every suite: the books, stock, places, signatures, meeting notes, AI agents and light seats for field staff.

  • Pro$25 par personne et par mois

    Everything, with no limit on apps, integrations or agents: payment links, connected apps, buying, insights, customer conversations, payroll, face checks, outside data and lessons.

Les équipes d'atelier ou de terrain se connectent avec des licences allégées à $1 par mois chacune. Payez un an et deux mois sont offerts.

Tous les tarifs de ProHQ

Lequel vous convient

Choisissez Koha si

  • A public, college or school library with a trained librarian who needs MARC cataloguing, holds, serials and acquisitions.
  • A library network that shares records between branches and with other libraries over the standard protocols.
  • A library with a technical person, or a budget for a support company, that wants no licence fee and its data on its own server.
  • A library that fits kiosks and gates speaking SIP2 or NCIP.

Choisissez ProHQ si

  • A community library or readers' club that wants to be lending this week, with nothing to install.
  • A library that runs on membership fees, points, referrals, coupons and events as much as on books, with readers doing their part from their own phones.
  • A team that wants AI doing the work: an assistant that answers from the records and acts, and agents that chase what is owed.
  • A place where the desk, the volunteers and the readers each want their own language, and reminders on WhatsApp.
  • A library with rules of its own, which would sooner describe them and have the app made than hire a developer.
  • A school, trust or club that wants its staff, pay, buying and books in the same place as its library.

Aussi recherché

Koha à côté des autres.

Koha vs Libib

Koha and Libib sit at opposite ends. Koha is a full library system with no licence fee, installed on a server or hosted by a vendor, with MARC, authorities, acquisitions, serials, recalls and a fines ledger. Libib is a hosted service, filled by scanning an ISBN with a phone, where lending and patrons come on Pro at $9 a month or $99 a year and paid plans stop at 100,000 items. Libib has its own iOS and Android apps, which Koha officially does not, and its help describes no fines at all.

Libib vs ProHQ

Quitter Koha

The Koha project states that libraries can export their data at any time. Its reports save as CSV, tab-separated text or ODS, so titles, items with their barcodes and patrons can each be saved as a file and brought into ProHQ's Library app from a sheet; the assistant can read a file and add the rows for you. Keep each barcode as the copy's spine code so the stickers stay good, and bring open loans and unpaid charges as their own lists.

Koha et ProHQ : les questions que l'on pose

Is Koha really free? What does a library pay?

The software is free under the GPL, with no fee for each user. What a library pays for sits around it: a Linux server and someone to run it, or a support company. Most companies quote. One that prints prices, Prosentient Systems, lists hosting at about 2,320 a year for each library or branch, plus 600 for setup and 1,200 for configuration, in a currency its page does not name.

Is ProHQ a good Koha alternative for a small community library?

For a readers' club or community library, often yes. ProHQ's Library app is ready on the first day with members, loans, fines, points, referrals, coupons and events, and readers use their own phones. A library that must catalogue in MARC or exchange records with other libraries is the one Koha was written for.

Does Koha work offline?

Partly. Koha's manual describes a Firefox add-on and a Windows tool that record check-outs and check-ins while the system is down, in a file uploaded once it is back. Cataloguing and the public catalogue need the server, and there is nothing for a phone. ProHQ keeps working on a weak signal on any device and sends the work when the network returns.

Does Koha have a mobile app?

The Koha project has no official phone app. Its public catalogue has a mobile view, so readers search, place holds and renew in a browser, and staff use the website. ProHQ is one app on Android, iOS and a computer, and a reader's phone is their library card: they scan a spine to borrow and ask to return from the same screen.

Does Koha have an AI assistant?

Koha itself has none; one support company lists AI-enabled searching extensions as a paid extra. In ProHQ the assistant is part of the platform. A librarian asks who has a book, what is overdue or who owes a fine, by typing or talking in their own language, and can tell it to add a member or waive a fee, within what their role may do.

What does ProHQ do that a library system does not?

It runs the rest of the organisation. Beside the Library app the same account holds buying from suppliers, the books, staff attendance, leave and payroll, tasks, documents and chat, with more than 80 apps connected. A school or trust that would run Koha beside an accounts package and an HR tool has them in one place, and can describe any further app it needs.

Can I move my Koha catalogue to ProHQ?

Yes. Koha's own pages say a library can export its data at any time, and its reports save as CSV or ODS. Save titles, items and patrons as files and bring them into the Library app. Keep each item's barcode as its spine code so the stickers still work, and check open loans by hand on the first morning.

Which needs less technical skill to run?

ProHQ. There is no server, no upgrade and no query language, and each staff role gets a lesson played inside the real app. Koha asks for a Linux server and somebody to maintain it, unless a support company hosts it. In return Koha can be shaped at the level of its code, and reports beyond its wizards are written in SQL.

L'avis franc

Koha is the right answer for a library run as a library in the professional sense: catalogued in MARC, with holds, serials and acquisitions, by people trained for it. It costs nothing to license and goes as deep as you need. ProHQ is the right answer when the library is part of something wider, a club, a school or a trust: its Library app handles members, loans, fines, points and events on readers' phones, and the same platform carries the staff, the money, AI that does the chasing and any app you describe.

Parlons-en maintenant

Appelez ProHQ. Notre IA décroche.

Réservez une démonstration avec notre équipe.

Composez-le avec +91 ou 0 devant.
Écoutez notre IA au téléphone La même IA qui répond à vos clients. Elle réserve aussi votre démo. +91 8064 270 270 Composez-le avec +91 ou 0 devant.

Parlez à notre IA

Parlez dans votre langue. Elle répond à vos questions et réserve votre démo avec notre équipe.

Dites-nous d'abord qui vous êtes, pour que notre équipe puisse vous recontacter.

Nous les utilisons uniquement pour vous contacter au sujet de ProHQ.

Votre navigateur demande l'accès à votre micro.